Tell me more ×
Quantitative Finance Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for finance professionals and academics. It's 100% free, no registration required.
up vote 0 down vote favorite

Why C is still in use especially in area of numerical optimization (instead of C++) ? C and C++ aren't fully compatible so mayby you know some differances that make the difference ?

share|improve this question
4  
Ugh, I wish I had seen this question earlier so I could close it. Too late now since enough people have chimed in. But I swear if this shows up on Hacker News or some garbage like that, I will burniate this. – chrisaycock♦ Feb 27 at 3:25
4  
Feel free to close it. There is no value-added; same question has been asked a bazillion times already... – Dirk Eddelbuettel Feb 27 at 3:35
2  
People voting for this obviously derive value. And why would it be too late to close it if the same question was asked already? Ironically if the question was about R or Matlab I do not think we would see above comments. – Freddy Feb 27 at 8:35
In such a general form it fits Computational Science much more than here – Alexey Kalmykov Feb 27 at 11:06
@AlexeyKalmykov They aren't going to want it either. Nor would Stack Overflow or Programmers.SE take it. It's just a really awful question. – chrisaycock♦ Feb 27 at 12:16
show 2 more comments

closed as not constructive by Danil Asotsky, Dirk Eddelbuettel, Clebson Derivan, chrisaycock♦ Feb 27 at 12:19

As it currently stands, this question is not a good fit for our Q&A format. We expect answers to be supported by facts, references, or specific expertise, but this question will likely solicit debate, arguments, polling, or extended discussion. If you feel that this question can be improved and possibly reopened, see the FAQ for guidance.

3 Answers

up vote 4 down vote

who told you that ? I am used to create new trade systems in C++ to make the customers requirements feasible.

CERN used C++ to prove higgs boson particle. I see people using C to program embedded like microwaves or fridges :D

but it is just my opnion, I would like to hear others.

share|improve this answer
are you referring to root.cern.ch/drupal ? amazing software +1 – pyCthon Feb 27 at 2:50
1  
yup and they are porting it to C++11 – Clebson Derivan Feb 27 at 11:04
up vote 4 down vote

C is not used for any particular reason in numerical optimizations other than for legacy reasons. However, there are areas where C is preferred over C++ though even C is not the preferred language of choice. To mind comes programming FPGAs. Though VHDL and Verilog are by far the standards. But "behavioral synthesis" allows to utilize C or C relatives such as SystemC to transfer logic to HDL. In that C is the preferred choice over C++. (Though having started working with FPGAs I start to get the sense that VHDL and Verilog are so popular for good reasons; even though the learning curve is a lot steeper they are much closer to the core of the particular hardware logic (Gate Arrays have a vastly different structure than a CPU).

So, C has its applications and is the preferred choice of weapon in some areas but more often than not people prefer using what they are best at. At least in numerical optimization I do not see a single reason why C would be preferred over C++ and actually I doubt such claim.

share|improve this answer
1  
FPGA's might not be a good fit for certain numerical optimization problems – pyCthon Feb 27 at 2:33
1  
@pyCthon, that was not my point, the point was to show an example in where it makes sense to have C be the preferred language over C++ and to explain why it is that case. By the way, as you already touched on it, FPGAs might not but can be an excellent fit for solving optimization problems. – Freddy Feb 27 at 3:03
I understand what you said pyCthon in fact when you need I/O you must think in a CPU like RISC. FGPA runs the whole application in one clock cycle. to create complex applications (eg to calculate a exotic derivative or option) IMHO FPGA is only part of the process. I mean, I could use it to decode market data in a fast way, replacing the ethernet card but I need a software to manage the data and coordinate not only the input but also the output when I need to send an order to a exchange for example. – Clebson Derivan Feb 27 at 11:12
@ClebsonDerivan, with all due respect but please look up the websites of Altera and Xilinx, you will notice that they heavily target Risk Management processes which do involve optimizations. But can we kind of stay on topic if possible? Again, this was just an example where C is preferred over C++. – Freddy Feb 27 at 11:16
1  
Freddy top500.org/lists/2012/11 all top computers are CPU/GPU based – Clebson Derivan Feb 27 at 11:25
show 1 more comment
up vote 0 down vote

I don't know how widely used C is over C++ when it comes to doing numerical optimization; however, if there is a preference towards C it likely comes from the fact that C++ name mangling is not standard making C++ libraries very hard to integrate into other languages and environments. With C you get a well known calling convention making it straightforward to integrate which is why you see C (and Fortran) libraries that are used in Python, R, Ruby, Java, C#, etc.

share|improve this answer
2  
I think I disagree with this assertion. C++ projects like Boost, Eigen, Armadillo, half a dozen ML libraries, ... all do very well with C++ interfaces. And if you must, you can always use a C interface for glue (as eg offered by R and used by Rcpp). – Dirk Eddelbuettel Feb 27 at 2:17
Same here, if you are looking for a single language that is most perused to disseminate APIs, on which other libraries rely, whose interfaces are accessed/invoked, then it is surly C++. Plus do not forget that by far the still most supported of all financial APIs in aggregate is the C++ one. I think that speaks for itself. – Freddy Feb 27 at 2:24

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.