This is a practice question for an exam:

  1. Consider a market consisting of a bank account with a constant interest rate $r$ and a stock $S$. The stock pays a proportional dividend of size $\delta S(T_{0-})$ at time $T_0$. Consider a $T$-claim that pays $X = S(T)$ at time $T$, where $T > T_0$.

a) What is the arbitrage-free price of $X$ at time $0$?

b) Find a replicating strategy for $X$

For the first question, if we assume that volatility of the stock is constant (i.e Black-Scholes), then we have the relation

$$\Pi_{\delta}(t,s) = \Pi(t,(1-\delta)s)$$ where $\Pi_{\delta},\Pi$ are the pricing functions for a claim on the underlying with and without dividends respectively, and since the price of the claim $X=S(T)$ (in a non-dividend context) is simply $\Pi(t) = s$, where $S(t) = s$, we get
$$\Pi_{\delta}(t,s) = s(1-\delta)$$ for all $t$.

The question for me now, is if it is reasonable to assume the Black Scholes model holds? I have no idea how one would approach it otherwise, is there a way to do it more generally?

For the second question I figure that we can buy the stock at $t=0$, and short $\delta$ units of the stock. At time $T_0$ we can use the dividend to settle our short position, and so the portfolio would pay out exactly $S(T)$ at time $T$. Does that make sense?

  • 2
    $\begingroup$ Note that: $S(T_0^+) = (1-\delta)S(T_0^-)$, where $T_0^-$ refers to the value before the dividend payment and $T_0^+$ after the payment. Hence, regarding your last paragraph, your dividends at $T_0^+$ will have value $\delta S(T_0^-)$ whereas your short position at $T_0^+$ will have value $-\delta S(T_0^+)=-\delta (1-\delta) S(T_0^-)$, so that strategy does not work. $\endgroup$ – Daneel Olivaw Jan 8 '18 at 17:21

a) From the no arbitrage condition, and without ressorting to a specific model $$ PV[S(T)|S(T_0)] = S(T_0) $$ $$ S(T_0) = (1-\delta) S(T_0^-) $$ $$ PV[S(T_0^-)|S(0)] = S(0) $$ Therefore the PV of $X$ at time $0$ is $$ PV[S(T)|S(0)] = PV[S(T_0)|S(0)] = PV[(1-\delta) S(T_0^-)|S(0)] = (1-\delta) S(0) $$


  • on $t=0$ you buy $1-\delta$ units of the stock
  • on $t=T_0$ you get a total dividend amount of $(1-\delta) \delta S(T_0^-)$ which you use to buy an additional $(1-\delta) \delta S(T_0^-)/S(T_0) = \delta$ units of stock, so that you now hold $1-\delta + \delta=1$ unit of stock
  • on $t=T$ you sell your $1$ unit of stock to replicate the payoff $X$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.