Just to be clear: please provide the 2 dates you are pricing your package at and the values of the spot and IV on each of those pricings.
Also you are pricing very short dated options immediately before earnings and there was very sharpe move (unsurprisingly). So it seems pretty clear that your greeks will move!
It is obvious you need to perform some earnings scenario analysis before putting up short date structure like this.
Also greeks are model dependent and those are american options do you know anything about your pricer ?
Eventually it is unclear the meaning of your “IV vs profit” plot. There are 4 options involved here.
All in all it seems you are providing very partial information so conditional on what you gave, everything is possible