0
$\begingroup$

In covered interest arbitrage, if the forward rate is too high, you can (i) exchange domestic for foreign currency today (ii) invest at the foreign deposit rate (iii) exchange back to the domestic currency at the "too high" rate, and you have beaten the rate you could have gotten by just investing domestically. Mathematically, this is just $$ F > S\frac{1 + i_d}{1 + i_f} \implies 1 + i_d < \frac{F}{S}\frac{1 + i_f}{1 + i_d} $$ where $F$ is the forward rate, $S$ is the current exchange rate, $i_d$ is the domestic interest rate, and $i_f$ is the foreign interest rate.

How do you perform arbitrage if the forward rate is instead too low? All examples I have seen are for the "too high" case.

$\endgroup$
2
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ First, investors in the foreign county could do the opposite of what you described. You could borrow foreign currency, exchange to home currency, invest at home rates and enter in the forward agreement and earn riskless profits in foreign currency (which you can convert back). The latter assumes you can borrow at $r_f$, which is typically not true in reality. $\endgroup$
    – fesman
    May 1 at 15:57
  • $\begingroup$ A big bank (or a big investor) may not even need to borrow the foreign currency, many times they already have the foreign currency in one of their foreign accounts and can use it to do the arbitrage in the reverse direction (essentially they borrow from themselves). $\endgroup$
    – noob2
    May 2 at 11:46
2
$\begingroup$

I do not like foreign and domestic. It frequently causes confusion, also by people who work in the market (@Ethan S, you use what is widely used, so excuse my rant).

I decide to demonstrate with GBPUSD (CCY1CCY2); GBP is foreign, USD domestic since it's quoted in units of domestic currency per unit of foreign currency. In other words, if S=1.4, one needs 1.4 USD to get one GBP.

Now, assume GBP interest is 2%, USD rate is 1% and the forward is 1.3. Fair FWD according to CIP is well above the actual market quoted forward. enter image description here

Simple introductory textbooks assume borrowing and lending is at the same rate and there is no restriction to borrow abroad. Now, it is optimal to borrow in GBP, and invest in USD.

enter image description here

As @fesman points out; can you borrow abroad? Could just say it is always only one side of the pond that can do this arbitrage? Well, the actual question is, can you invest abroad? The answer is not so different really. From a retail investor side, the answer is probably not. That said more than one in five Polish mortgages was held in Swiss francs.

However, the FX and rates interbank market is something vastly different. There is strong competition and low regulatory burden, which results in very small spreads between interest rates at which banks are willing to pay for deposits and the interest rates that banks charge for loans. The Eurodollar market is very liquid. Moreover, there is a very liquid cross currency swap market. You should actually take this basis into consideration when doing the exercise.

One could argue this is all very much US centered thinking but even if the transaction is between COP and ARS, USD plays a role as one could always do the series of transactions via USD.

This is what professional tools computing this are doing. E.g. on Bloomberg, one can use FXFA to check CIP or imply any direction. It is displaying sided pricing (bid-ask), and flexible in terms of interest rates being used (LIBOR, OIS...).

Even if you were to find apparent arbitrage, it is likely that after considering all aspects (regulation in different countries, tax implications, default risk of counterparties, political risk, exchange controls..), this will quickly look unlikely to be riskless arbitrage. Ex-ante, you never know what happens...

$\endgroup$
0
$\begingroup$

Yes If forward is lower than the forward you can get via the strategy of shorting the underlying and investing the proceeds , then do that strategy and simultaneously buy forward and voila youve locked in profits :)

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.