I have observed that IV is increasing with time to maturity by using market prices and plotting IV (from Black-Scholes) against log-moneyness, $\log(S_t/K)$. $S_t$ being the price of the stock at time $t$ and $K$ being the strike.

Using Martingales we can prove that the call-option's payoff function - i.e. $\max(S_t-K, 0)$ - is a submartingale under the $Q$-measure. Now this article from Columbia says that the call-price as a function of time to expiry, that is $C_t(T)$, must be not-decreasing to avoid arbitrage, which can be shown using standard martingale results - but why is that?

What are the calculations performed by "standard martinale results" which imply that if the call price was decreasing as a function of $T$ then there would be an arbitrage?

The argument that I do not understand is highlighted here: enter image description here


For $r=q=0$ and $t\leq T'\leq T$:

$$ C_t(T)=E_{t}[(S_T -K)^+] = E_{t}[E_{T'}[(S_T -K)^+] \geq E_t[(S_{T'} -K)^+]=C_t(T'),$$

where we used the tower property of conditional expectation and the sub-martingality of $(S_{T'}-K)^+$ they mentioned (which is a consequence of Jensen inequality for conditional expectation).

A calendar spread (one long call with expiry $T$ and one short call with expiry $T'$) with negative price would violate the above inequality.

  • $\begingroup$ Thanks for showing that calculations! Would you mind explaining why this then results in the statement "the term structure of implied volatility cannot be too inverted"? $\endgroup$ – Kenno Jun 9 at 6:36
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ If the pricing of the calls is done via standard Black-Scholes functional $BS_t$, then $ C_t(T) = BS_t(T; \sigma)$ and $C_t(T') = BS_t(T'; \sigma') $ for some vol parameters $\sigma$ and $\sigma'$. You can experiment with very low $\sigma$ and very high $\sigma'$ to see if the inequality above gets broken. $\endgroup$ – ir7 Jun 9 at 14:32
  • $\begingroup$ I'll try calculating some different values. What exactly is $B$ in your formula? I've only seen $B$ in the notation of the 'Risk Free Assest' (i.e. the bank account). $\endgroup$ – Kenno Jun 9 at 19:23
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ BS stands for the standard Black-Scholes formula itself. $\endgroup$ – ir7 Jun 9 at 19:27

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.